A History of… The Hobbit


Lashaan recently wrote up a review of his first time reading The Hobbit. Great review and I highly recommend you read it. But it got me to thinking. I literally grew up with the Hobbit and thought I’d try to remember my life as defined by the experiences I was going through when I read and re-read the Hobbit.

I believe that my experience with the Hobbit started before I could even read. My mom used to read to me in the afternoons before I started going to school and I know she read me Narnia and the Little House on the Prairie series. I can’t remember her explicitly reading me the Hobbit but my familiarity with it in later years leads me to believe she did. I don’t remember too much of that time overall except for a warm fuzzy sense of “rightness”. 

The next instance of the Hobbit is an explicit memory, one very well defined. I believe I was in middleschool and our family was going up to Canada to visit the Grands. I went to the library and got the Hobbit so I would have a book to read. Even then I knew to always have a book handy. It was one with the faux-leather green cover.

Not sure it was this exact edition, but if not, it looked almost like it

I remember this so well because on the way home we stopped in Maine at some relatives and I got a wicked bad sunburn on my whole back (didn’t use sunscreen) and we had to travel for 12hrs in the car the next day. You don’t forget experiences like that!

In highschool I wrote a paper on the Hobbit and Tolkien. I don’t have that paper handy nor do I remember anything about it, except, I got to read the Hobbit and use it to do some school work. Score!

Jump forward in time to Bibleschool in the late 90’s. One of our professors read through the entire series on Friday nights and Saturday afternoons to us students in one of the rooms that had couches and comfy chairs. When you are 19-22, having a chance to just hang out with everyone and not actually do anything is great. Add in that we all liked the story, the Professor had done this for years and so had a fantastic voice for reading, well, it was all a nerd could ask for.

Aye, aye Captain Professor Sir!

In 2001 the SFBC came out with the omnibus edition of the Lord of the Rings. I bought that and the Hobbit at the same time. Why should I pay for 4 books when I could pay for just 2? Small print didn’t mean a thing to my eyes then and being thrifty meant more than anything.

Teensy tiny print

In 2006 I met Miss Librarian at a friend’s wedding (Miss Library and I had been friends online) and we exchanged books. I gave her a copy of the Hobbit.

It was this edition

2 years later we were married and suddenly there were 2 copies of the same book on our book shelves. 2008 was a year for surprises, that is for sure!

Fast forward 3 years to 2011. I was on Goodreads and loving it. I had book friends and was writing reviews left and right. One of my online friends re-read the whole series every year. I wasn’t as much into re-reading then myself, but he inspired me to go through them all. I was simply blown away by how well written the Hobbit was and at how it could still appeal to my mature 30’something self. You’re Mature at 30 and after that you’re just Old and who cares what Old People think.

And now we come to 2019. Devilreads is a bad memory, 30 is just a stage that I grew out of (into a much more Mature stage I must say!) and yet here I am reading the Hobbit again and still loving it.

Bad Memories Indeed

What do you call a book that enthralls a 4 to 5 year old (no matter how precocious), a middleschooler, a highschooler, someone in college, a mid 20’s man, a 30 year old in his prime and then a 40 year old with the wisdom of the ages under his belt? If Classic doesn’t fit, then I don’t know what would. As sagacious as I currently am, I suspect in another 10-15 years that I’ll STILL love this book.

I’d like to take the time to thank Lashaan once again. He’s inspired several of these A History of… posts. The more years I collect, the more memories tag along, except for when I forget them. So it is good to write them down before they disappear 😀

34 thoughts on “A History of… The Hobbit

  1. salonimore1702 says:

    I loved this post! It’s wonderful how in a turbulent life, the one constant is a book you love and has stayed with you for so long.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. I read The Hobbit for the first time in 2015, so I was 28. I really loved it. I had a harder time with Fellowship of the Ring, although I still liked it. I own the last two books and really need to continue.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Bookstooge says:

      I completely understand having a harder time with LotR. It is a very different beast than the Hobbit and while I still enjoy them, I don’t automatically assume that if someone loves one that they will love the other.

      Just like I can’t stand Tolkien’s Silmarillion!

      Liked by 1 person

  3. H.P. says:

    I’ve written a little bit about my history with The Hobbit. I was reading some sort of fantasy (I don’t remember what) and my told me that if I liked it then I would like The Hobbit. I didn’t want to read it because I was a snobbish kid (I was 10 or younger at the time). Eventually I relented to my great joy!

    My original copy had a really hideous 90s movie-style cover. I bought that green cover edition to read to no-angel in the womb. I wound up effectively reading The Hobbit three times last year: once aloud to the baby (extending to post-birth), once in the usual fashion, and once as a part of the Rateliff book, which basically includes the entire text. That experience did nothing to dissuade me of my view that The Hobbit is the perfect fantasy book.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Bookstooge says:

      I think know those covers you are talking about! I owned them as well until I lent them to a friend and he took them to his public school and I never saw them again.

      Hopefully No-Angel can appreciate what you’ve done for her already!


  4. I’ve loved The Hobbit all of my life, too. We had a text adventure game version of it, too, back when the Commodore 64 was all the rage. It was a bunch of fun.

    Liked by 1 person

  5. Awesome post! Really nice to see a book that you loved this book at all those different moments. I have that with Lord of the Rings. My parents got it for their wedding, so my dad was eager to introduce us to the story. I think I saw the movies first (the first one at least), and we listened to the audiobooks in the car on holiday. Many rereads later it was then also the first book I read in English, and then also wrote a paper about it and Tolkien for our ‘culture and art’ class. My only 10 out of 10 I ever scored. Have reread it many times since. It is one of the very few books, if not the only, I could keep rereading. Actually love it so much that I convinced Dave that if we have a son one day to name him after one of the characters. From the Dutch translation that is 😋
    We listened to the hobbit after lotr, and then I thought it was just fine. It wasn’t lotr, and I missed those characters. I have reread it a few times now though, and I like it better with every read.
    Wow, this comment got a lot longer than I was planning… sorry not sorry

    Liked by 1 person

    • Bookstooge says:

      Never apologize for a LONG comment on this blog 😀 I love them!

      That is really cool about growing up with LotR! Do the dutch translations change the names? Honestly, I would have thought those stayed the same.

      Liked by 1 person

      • Most are the same, but merry and pippin are merijn and pepijn. Baggins became Balings. Samwise Gamgee became Sam Gewissies. And some names like Cotton got literal translations. Most stayed the same though. I guess in some cases (like gamgee) we would pronounce it so differently it would have a completely different feel to it.

        Liked by 1 person

  6. Really fun post. The Hobbit is definitely a work of art. Something exciting happens in every single chapter.

    I don’t remember the first time The Hobbit was read to me, but I do remember we had this little vinyl record of a kids’ version of it that went with an illustrated book. The illustrations were great – not too cutesy, kind of ugly actually. Those illustrations still form my mental picture of Bilbo Baggins. And now my niece loves them.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Bookstooge says:

      Would that happen to be the Bass&Rankin version? I didn’t realize it as a kid, but my goodness, the movie and the book were ugly as all get out!

      Glad to hear that others have experienced the Hobbit from childhood on. Gives me hope that that can be passed along 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

  7. HCNewton says:

    Love this post

    Liked by 2 people

  8. The song goes that diamonds are a girl’s best friends, but I strongly believe that books (and these books in particular) are everyone’s best friends – for life, as you delightful walk through memory lane shows 🙂
    Thanks for sharing!!!!

    Liked by 1 person

    • Bookstooge says:

      There really aren’t too many books that I can point to as books that I’ve read at almost every stage of life. I doubt there are many books that most people can do that to. I wish there were more…

      Liked by 1 person

  9. Loved reading your history of the hobbit!! Especially because it was so intrinsic to my childhood too and is something I’ve returned to again and again. It’s definitely a book that will never get old either because it’s so well written. It’s really amazing that it’s been such a big part of every stage of your life!

    Liked by 1 person

  10. […] A History of… The Hobbit—Probably my favorite blog post of the week—Bookstooge, longtime Friend of IRR, talks about his personal history with the classic. […]


  11. I really appreciate that you took the time to do this, good sir. Honestly, it means a lot, in the sense that I didn’t exactly get the chance to have parents who knew what The Hobbit was or even thought of reading such books to their kids before bed or anything. Hearing your story tells me how books can be so significant to us, even at an age where we don’t even care for them. It’s also amazing how many different editions you went through! I can imagine myself collecting them all someday (at the moment, I won’t even try hahah). Also, I too should thank you for continuously repeating how awesome The Hobbit was over the past blogging years. It definitely played a role in me picking it up now rather than… later/never.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Bookstooge says:

      Glad you enjoyed the post. The older I get the more I realize how blessed I was to have parents who encouraged me to read. Visits to the library were a weekly occurrence and I just thought of them as normal. Now I realize just how significant those visits actually were.

      I really enjoyed your review of the Hobbit and I hope you can enjoy the Lord of the Rings when you get around to them.

      Liked by 1 person

  12. Paul S says:

    I have a similar history with The Hobbit. I first read it as school and I’ve still got my childhood paperback copy, I still dip into it several times a year. A classic indeed.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Bookstooge says:

      Nice! I don’t have any old copies. I almost wish I did but we were a library family back then. It wasn’t until I got out on my own with money that I really started collecting books. 🙂

      Thanks for stopping by.

      Liked by 1 person

  13. […] – after 13 years of hearing about it I finally gave in to the general pressure (except you, Bookstooge, I know you hate Evilreads with all your might – maybe with the exception of these nice […]


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s